The New York Mets (22-28) return to the scene of the crime (the conclusion of their 2025 collapse) as they prepare to seek some revenge against the Miami Marlins (22-29). You will remember that the Amazins were shut out 4-0 in the final game of the 2025 season, which prevented them from earning a postseason spot as the Reds also lost their final game of the season. That game also helped Miami steal the season series from New York, taking seven of the 13 games that the two teams played.
The team’s series against the Nationals was a mixed bag, resulting in a 2-2 split in Washington DC. The team sandwiched the series win wins, 16-7 on Monday and 2-1 on Thursday, while enduring rough losses in the middle of 9-6 on Tuesday and 8-4 on Wednesday. The wins could not have been any different, as they used a 10-run twelfth inning to bludgeon the Nationals after escaping the first nine innings tied at 5-5. They originally trailed 3-1, then grabbed a 5-3 lead, then slowly let that slip away when the Nationals tied it in the eighth. It’s not often you see a position player pitching in extra innings. Then in the series finale, the team that has scored the most runs in the league and given up the most runs in the league only scored one and allowed two, which was enough for the Mets to earn the hard fought victory, courtesy of David Peterson and a great performance from the bullpen.
The two middle games were incredibly sloppy and disheartening, especially for a team that, coming into Tuesday night, had won six of its last seven contests. You could make a case for Tuesday being the team’s worst loss of 2026, as they blew past Washington in the early innings, building a 5-0 lead on the back of two two-run homers from a suddenly-rejuvenized Bo Bichette. With Nolan McLean on the mound, the Mets and the Flushing Faithful felt like this on in the bag, but it was not to be, as McLean was not as sharp as he normally is, and the defense let him down. This game featured an inside the park grand slam, which is another wacky rarity you don’t see much these days. Wednesday featured Zach Thornton’s major league debut, which did not go great, as the Nats’ bats jumped all over him early. Juan Soto tried to keep the Mets in this one, hitting two monstrous home runs along the way, but it was not enough for New York.
One positive to take away from the team’s recent series was the play of Bichette, who came to life after looking lifeless for much of the early portion of the season. Entering Monday with just two homers on the season, he hit three in the four games, and hit the decisive two-run single in the third inning of Thursday’s win. Overall, he went 7-for-18 in the series while driving in nine of the team’s 28 runs and scoring five of them. Juan Soto continued his torrid pace, recording 6 hits in 16 at-bats with three homers of his own. Dating back to May 14, he has five homers in his last eight games.
There is probably nothing more encouraging than the recent play of top prospect Carson Benge, who led the club with eight hits in the series. Over the month of May, he’s slashing .351/.400/.459 and is second to Soto with an .859 OPS. This is especially encouraging after he finished April with a .189/.247/.289 slash line and a team-worst .525 OPS (among qualified hitters). He’s shown a quick adjustment after a slow start, especially as he’s learned to hit pitchers that are higher in the zone and muscle them into the outfield for hits, something we’ve seen a lot more in recent days. Benge is second in the NL in batting average during the month of May.
The only person who has a higher batting average is Otto Lopez (.370), who suits up for the last place Marlins. The Marlins lost three of four to the Braves, falling 8-4, 9-1, and 9-3 after stunning Atlanta 12-0 in the opening game of the series. The three losses, paired with New York’s win yesterday, moved Miami into last place in the National League East.
As mentioned, Lopez leads the team in batting average in May, as well as wRC+ (144) and OPS (.870). On the season, the shortstop is slashing .342/.373/.487 with a 140 wRC+ and a team-best 2.2 fWAR. The only person with a higher wRC+ is Xavier Edwards at 149. Edwards enters play hitting .316/.395/.484 with a 2.0 fWAR in a team-high 51 games. Their catcher, Liam Hicks, leads the way with nine home runs and 42 runs batted in (exactly double the player who is second on their team, which is also Lopez). He owns a 126 wRC+ and a 0.9 fWAR in 48 games.
Friday, May 22: Tobias Myers vs. Eury Pérez, 7:10 PM EDT on WPIX
Myers (2026): 29.0 IP. 23 K, 6 BB, 5 HR, 3.41 ERA, 4.38 IP, 87 ERA-
Myers has been a weapon for the Mets out of the pen this year, acting as a swiss army knife who is versatile enough to take on many roles. He can give them length, or pitch one high leverage inning to preserve a lead, and now he will take on a new role as a starter to give Freddy Peralta, Christian Scott, and Nolan McLean an extra day of rest. With the Mets in the middle of a 16-games-in-16-days stretch, those pitchers have logged a lot of innings, so the rest will do them some good. This is technically Myers’ second start of the year, as he served as an opener and pitched two shutout innings against the Cubs back on April 19 in an eventual loss.
Pérez (2026): 52.1 IP, 58 K, 28 BB, 10 HR, 5.33 ERA, 5.21 FIP, 129 ERA-
Pérez has had a rough start to his 2026 campaign, with an ERA that’s over one run higher than his final line from 2025. Since earning his second win of the season back on April 19—an outing that saw him allow just one unearned run on three hits with seven strikeouts over six innings against the Brewers—the right-hander has lost each of his last five starts. In that stretch, he’s allowed 19 earned runs over 26 1/3 innings (6.49 ERA). In that stretch, he’s walked 16, struck out 31, and has posted a 5.77 FIP. He’s allowed at least four earned runs in three of those five starts.
Saturday, May 23: Freddy Peralta vs. Max Meyer, 4:10 PM EDT on SNY
Peralta (2026): 54.1 IP, 54 K, 25 BB, 6 HR, 3.31 ERA, 4.05 FIP, 84 ERA-
In his last start against the Yankees, Peralta allowed three earned runs on two hits over five-plus innings, with two of the three runs crossing the plate after he exited the game. The right-hander didn’t do himself any favors, as he walked a season-high six while striking out four. In fact, just 44 of the 96 pitches (46%) he ended up throwing were strikes, and it’s generally rare to see a starting pitcher throw fewer than 50% of their pitches for strikes. For the record, that’s the most batters he’s walked in a game since issuing six free passes as a member of the Brewers back on May 5, 2024.
Meyer (2026): 53.2 IP, 60 K, 19 BB, 4 HR, 2.85 ERA, 3.07 FIP, 69 ERA-
Meyer, the third overall pick int he 2022 MLB Draft, has broken out in this, his fourth big league season for the Marlins. The right-hander, who posted a -0.1 bWAR in two starts in 2022, a -0.2 bWAR in 11 starts in 2024(he missed all of 2023 with injuries) and a 0.0 bWAR in 12 starts last year, has posted a 1.7 bWAR in 10 starts for Miami this year. He’s currently ninth in the NL in HR/9 (0.67) and ninth in K% (26.7%) while also posting a very respectable 8.4% BB%. His last time out, he shut out the Braves over six innings, scattering three hits while striking out six and walking two.
Sunday, May 24: Christian Scott vs. TBD, 1:40 PM EDT on SNY
Scott (2026):19.2 IP, 25 K, 12 BB, 1 HR, 4.12 ERA, 3.67 FIP, 105 ERA-
The Mets have won four of Scott’s five outings so far this year, but he has yet to factor in the decision for any of them and enters this start still seeking his first career major league victory. The right-hander lasted just four innings his last time out while allowing three earned runs (a season high) on four hits. He walked three and struck out five, and his pitch count reached 81, which led to his exit. He threw 49 of those pitches (60%) for strikes.
The Marlins have not named a starter for Sunday’s game.
