Over three months have now passed since Nancy Guthrie, the beloved mother of television personality Savannah Guthrie, was taken from her home in Tuscon, Arizona. Neither the local police department nor the FBI have produced any credible leads, but there’s no shortage of popular theories trailing the internet.
Guthrie disappeared from her home on February 1, 2026, and police quickly determined that she had been abducted against her will. In the days that followed, her family received several ransom notes demanding millions of dollars worth of cryptocurrency, which the FBI later determined to be fake.
There has been no further contact from the alleged kidnapper, and the only information authorities currently have to work with is forensic evidence from the scene—and images of a masked figure caught on a doorbell camera.
With the case passing the three-month mark over the weekend, NewsNation is looking back on the crime that’s gripped the United States with a special episode titled NewsNation Presents: The Nancy Guthrie Mystery. Previews of the TV special have already raised some fascinating questions.
The episode will be hosted by Brian Entin, the journalist who has covered the Nancy Guthrie case extensively from the beginning. He will be joined by criminal profilers Dr. Ann Burgess, Dr. Gary Brocato and Dr. Casey Jordan.
In exclusive footage obtained by Parade, the experts are discussing whether the man captured on Guthrie’s camera was acting alone, or whether the abduction was an organized effort with a “boss” elsewhere.
During the discussion, Burgess levels a new theory: “I just had a thought. That person [on Nancy’s stoop] may have been eliminated,” Dr. Burgess said. She goes on to explain that he could have been killed by the “boss” in order to cover his tracks.
“It was well-planned. They got away with it. And they pulled a type of case that we’ve never seen before, as far as we know,” she added.
Similar theories have been circulating the internet for months, but the police have always dismissed it as a credible solution. There has been no forensic evidence to even suggest the kidnapper was working in collaboration with anybody else, though it remains a popular theory.
Entin discussed his upcoming special with Parade: “I think people [will find the special] interesting because [the profilers] have some fascinating theories based on past cases they’ve worked, as well as statistics. They’re really focused on patterns in other crimes and kidnappings to help narrow down motive and who they think this [suspect] could be.”
NewsNation Presents: The Nancy Guthrie Mystery will air on CW TV on Wednesday, May 6 at 9 p.m. ET.
This story was originally published by Men’s Journal on May 5, 2026, where it first appeared in the News section. Add Men’s Journal as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
