Ever wondered what it’s like inside a big league clubhouse like after a blowout loss? I can tell you: it’s quiet.
At least, that’s what it was in the Kansas City Royals clubhouse after getting stomped 15-1 by the New York Yankees on Tuesday evening. Half a dozen or so players sat around a table, silently eating their postgame dinner. The faint sounds of the shower echoed through the hallway. Some players in street clothes, heads down, scrolled on their phones at their locker.
Wading through the foglike weariness politely trudged a small parade of reporters and writers. Three players were offered as a tribute to the ever-churning machine of sports media, as was manager Matt Quatraro in the media room a few minutes prior. The responses were pretty consistent.
“We were getting our brains beat in and nobody feels good,” Quatraro said.
“I’m extremely frustrated,” pitcher Bailey Falter said.
“It’s wearing on me,” first baseman Vinnie Pasquantino said.
Sometimes blowouts like these happen. But this particular loss had teeth. It’s the team’s 13th consecutive loss to the Yankees, two of which happened in the 2024 playoffs. More importantly, it sunk the Royals to 11 games below .500 and was their 14th loss in their last 19 games. Three weeks ago, the Royals were second in the American League Central with a 42.5% chance to make the playoffs, per Fangraphs. That figure has sunk to a lean 13.4%, a figure that feels too high and is only in the double-digits because pretty much everybody in the AL is having a rough go of it.
While the Royals won’t go on losing 75% of their games for the rest of the year like they have for the last two weeks, the players are stuck right now. Losing isn’t fun for anyone, let alone hypercompetitive athletes. “Nobody wants to stand there and watch that,” Quatraro said about the blowout against New York. “But that’s the reality of what happened in the game. There’s nowhere to go.”
Pasquantino echoed that thought. “We just got to keep moving forward and we don’t have a choice,” he said from his locker. “We’re not doing our jobs so we’ve got to get better. We’ve got to keep working hard and we’re going to do that. Like I said, we’ve got faith in this team. Just got to keep pushing forward.”
Vinnie’s thought process is a healthy one. Individual athletes can only really affect two things: their own performance and how good of a teammate they are. He’s committed to getting better to the best of his ability, and he’s tired of losing, but it’s a job and it’s important to keep things in perspective.
But there is a natural silhouette around those words about what athletes can’t do, what they are not employed to do. It is not their job to construct a roster or decide on strategy. It is not their job to evaluate the performance of the team or organization. When things go bad, it’s the players who have to go out there the day after getting blown out and compete in an incredibly difficult league against some of the best athletes in the world, in front of fans who could boo and heckle them. It’s the players putting their bodies on the line and risking damage that could impact the rest of their lives.
Earlier, Quatraro was asked how difficult it was to stay the course when things weren’t going their way during the course of the season. After the question, Q took a short but noticeable pause before answering. “I mean, there’s no alternative but to stay the course,” he said. “We’re not going to blow things up. These guys are working their butts off. We talk about it all the time. You got to trust in the people and the processes that you have and we got to go out there and play better.”
Ah, ‘the course.’ It is one thing to stay the course when the course is a proven path of success. The Royals simply haven’t established that. Yes, the team made the playoffs in 2024. But everything is clearer in hindsight: the further we get away from the season, the uncomfortable truth seems to be that they squeaked into the playoffs mainly through a combination of an incandescent Bobby Witt Jr. masterpiece of a season and the nearby presence of a historically bad, 121-loss Chicago White Sox club floundering about in Kansas City’s division. Without what amounted to a minor league team to beat up on and with a merely great-but-not-otherworldy Witt, the Royals’ course has been mediocre at best.
Vital to this discussion is the longevity of mediocrity going on: the Royals are now 114-132 over their last 244 regular season games, and it took them winning their last two games of 2025 to claw their way out from a losing season. This year, they’re on pace for 98 losses. I don’t need to tell you that this performance is unacceptable for a team that thinks of itself as a good team. They are going backwards.
But is it unacceptable? The players think so. I’m not sure team leadership does, at least not in a way that is impactful. See, there are a wide variety of moves that a team like this can do. Some of them are minor, like taking some creative approaches to lineup construction. Some are maybe a little more involved, like making a change at hitting coach or pitching coach or sending a struggling player back to the minors for a reset. Some of them are somewhat major or even organization-shaking, like making a change at manager or general manager. There are legitimate reasons to make or not make each of these moves, but if the Royals thought that they were a playoff team going into this year, something should have happened by now. We’ve gotten, well, nothing.
Quatraro has gotten a lot of heat lately, but JJ Picollo and John Sherman should be getting more than they are because it’s really their job to evaluate the performance of the entire baseball operations department. The players are giving it all they’ve got. It’s the team leadership that ought to be evaluating if the right players are in the right spots with the right coaching. It’s clearly evident that’s not happening.
The Royals were, of course, swept by the Yankees. They were, naturally, shut out in Wednesday’s game. They’re off on a 10-game road trip. Things might get worse before they get better. But to get better, Royals brass will have to set aside their egos and pay attention.
