It’s February 2026, and as the NHL pauses for the Milano-Cortina Olympics, the Vancouver Canucks find themselves in a position few would have predicted three years ago. While Bo Horvat pulls on the Maple Leaf for Team Canada, the franchise he once captained is picking up the pieces of a collapsed core.
Related: Canucks News & Rumours: Rossi, Boeser, Demko, Tolopilo & Koskenvuo
Looking back, the sliding doors moment for this organization wasn’t the 2024 playoff run or the eventual coaching changes. It was the winter of 2023 when management chose to keep J.T. Miller and ship Bo Horvat to Long Island. At the time, it looked like a calculated gamble on elite production. Today, it looks like a huge mistake.
The Culture Cost of a Talent Bet
In professional hockey, we often talk about “the room” as an abstract concept. In Vancouver, it became a tangible problem. The decision to keep Miller over Horvat was a bet that Miller’s on-ice output — which reached a staggering 103 points in 2024-25 — would outweigh the friction he generated in the locker room.
Former Vancouver Canucks forward Bo Horvat celebrates after a goal by forward J.T. Miller (Bob Frid-USA TODAY Sports)
The reality? That friction didn’t just persist; it caught fire. Reports have since confirmed a deep-seated rift between Miller and star forward Elias Pettersson that never truly healed. While Horvat was the homegrown leader who could bridge gaps between different personalities, Miller’s leadership style was often described as “troublesome” by those close to the team. By 2025, the culture had soured to the point where the organization felt forced to move Miller to the New York Rangers anyway. We’re left wondering: if Horvat stays, does that toxicity ever reach a breaking point?
The Captaincy Domino Effect
Perhaps the most painful fallout of the Horvat trade wasn’t even about Horvat himself, but about the man who inherited his ‘C’. When Quinn Hughes was named captain, it was heralded as a “new era.” Hughes is a generational talent, a defenceman who can control the flow of a game like few others. But the burden of being the face of a fractured locker room took a visible toll.
Without a veteran buffer like Horvat to handle the “noise” and the heavy lifting of leadership, Hughes was left to answer for every Miller outburst and every organizational misstep. By the end of 2025, the weight of the captaincy, combined with a team regressing toward the basement of the Pacific Division, led to the unthinkable: Hughes getting traded to the Minnesota Wild. Had Horvat stayed to insulate the young star, it’s highly probable that Hughes would still be patrolling the Vancouver blue line today, focusing on his Norris-caliber play rather than managing egos.
Diverging Paths on the Ice
While Miller provided a short-term jolt that led the Canucks to a division title in 2024-25, the long-term performance gap has swung heavily in Horvat’s favour. Since arriving in New York, he has evolved into a premier top-six centre, consistently hovering around the 30-goal mark and refining a 200-foot game that makes him a coach’s dream. His inclusion on the 2026 Olympic roster is a testament to his reliability and steady growth.
Feb 12, 2026; Milan, Italy; Bo Horvat of Canada scores their third goal against Czechia in a men’s ice hockey group A match during the Milano Cortina 2026 Olympic Winter Games at Milano Santagiulia Ice Hockey Arena. Mandatory Credit: Geoff Burke-Imagn Images
On the flip side, Miller’s decline has been steep. After that 103-point peak, his production plummeted, and his stint with the Rangers has been defined by inconsistency and a “snakebitten” scoring touch. As we stand here in 2026, the Canucks are essentially starting from scratch, while Horvat remains a pillar for a competitive Islanders squad.
The 2024-25 Mirage
To be fair to the front office, there was a window where they looked like geniuses. The 2023–24 season was a dream. The Canucks won the Pacific, Miller was a Hart Trophy candidate, and the assets from the Horvat trade were flipped to land Filip Hronek, who remains one of the few bright spots on the current roster.
But winning covers up a lot of cracks. The success of 2024-25 was built on a foundation of elite finishing and spectacular goaltending that simply wasn’t sustainable given the internal rot. Once the puck luck dried up and the locker room issues became public, the house of cards collapsed. The Hronek acquisition was a win, but it came at the cost of the team’s soul.
The Verdict
The NHL is a business of results, and the results are in. By choosing Miller’s volatility over Horvat’s stability, the Canucks didn’t just trade a player; they traded their identity. They traded a captain who wanted to be a “Canuck for life” for a player they ended up offloading anyway, and in the process, they lost the best defenceman in franchise history.
As we watch Horvat compete for gold in Italy, the takeaway is clear: you can replace 30 goals, but you can’t easily replace the glue that holds a championship-caliber room together.
AI tools were used to support the creation or distribution of this content, however, it has been carefully edited and fact-checked by a member of The Hockey Writers editorial team. For more information on our use of AI, please visit our Editorial Standards page.
