Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.
Streaking atop the Red Lobster website is a wraparound banner, divided into four frames, each containing videos of starry-eyed diners stuffing their faces with impossible amounts of shrimp. The shellfish is prepared in all applications: There is shrimp linguini, shrimp scampi, and deep-fried butterfly shrimp—bisected along the spine, opaque with breading, and submerged in marinara sauce. There is coconut shrimp with a sweet Polynesian glaze and “Marry Me Shrimp,” as in shrimp served in a tomato cream sauce, gesturing toward the viral chicken recipe of the same name. All are served on cerulean-trimmed platters piled high with wedged lemons and steamed broccoli. “YOU ASKED, WE LISTENED,” read the letters dancing across the screen that, despite their best intentions, brim with menace. “ENDLESS SHRIMP IS BACK.”
It’s true. As of April 20, the dwindling number of Red Lobster restaurants that still exist around the country—as in, those that survived a brutal purge in the summer of 2024, which saw the shuttering of more than 100 locations after the venerable seafood chain filed for bankruptcy—have resummoned their most popular, and most controversial, promotion. Recall that in 2023, Red Lobster, in a slump, made its previously once-in-a-blue-moon Endless Shrimp deal a permanent fixture on the menu. The name is self-explanatory: For $20, customers could order an infinite procession of shrimp, brought hot and fresh to their tables, with the only restriction being that diners must clean their plate before getting a refill. This was a dangerous proposition. Red Lobster seemed to be betting on the premise that the average American would tap out after one or two dishes, because, really, how much shrimp could anyone eat? But that turned out to be a hysterical underestimation of good old-fashioned American shamelessness. Diners cleaned out Endless Shrimp by the troughful, at rates that quickly proved to be hilariously unsustainable. Red Lobster would go on to report an $11 million operating loss on Endless Shrimp in the final quarter of 2023, accelerating the company’s nosedive. (Red Lobster halted the promotion shortly afterward.)
A lot of people have floated the idea that Red Lobster’s financial woes can be singularly ascribed to Endless Shrimp, likely because there was some Pynchonian irony in the idea that a restaurant chain that once facilitated a fine-dining image in the American hinterlands would be decisively shattered by vulgar, proletarian all-you-can-eat hubris. The truth is considerably more boring: Red Lobster filed for bankruptcy because the company was enmeshed in an extractive real estate deal, selling off its property holdings for a quick infusion of cash, only to lease them back at punitive rates—an arrangement representative of the stygian economic strip-mining currently sucking the life out of the modern consumer experience.
So Endless Shrimp was only a contributing factor to the meltdown, but that doesn’t change the fact that Red Lobster employees, by and large, hated the promotion. In 2024, I spoke to a number of the restaurant’s newly laid-off servers, who described the humiliation of ferrying bucketfuls of shellfish to gorging philistines. They recounted, in bitter detail, a dining room overwhelmed by a clientele reminiscent of the lounge-chair-bound hedonists in Wall-E. The specifics of their complaints won’t surprise you much: Endless Shrimp patrons, it turned out, didn’t tip very well, especially compared to the population that previously made up Red Lobster’s core demographic—kindly grandmothers eating dinner at 4:30 p.m. Also, more plainly, being around all of that shrimp was disgusting.
“I had a guy come in with his family. It was a family of five. And he did 16 rounds of shrimp scampi,” said a server who spoke to me at the time. “He was there for over two hours on a busy Friday night. They had one of my biggest tables. I just had to watch this man eat plates upon plates of the scampi, which isn’t even served over pasta. It’s shrimp in a garlic-wine butter. It was so gross.”
Given all this, it was legitimately surprising to me that Red Lobster was dusting off its Endless Shrimp gimmick. Why tempt the insatiable American maw again, especially after what happened last time? But the comeback is very much in line with Red Lobster’s ongoing rebrand, architected by its newly installed CEO, 37-year-old Damola Adamolekun, who earned himself some splashy coverage for his nouveau updates to the ancient menu, particularly the addition of Instagram-friendly seafood boils blooming with briny, fruit-punch-red broth. (Questions remain about whether this brand resuscitation will be effective—despite the glossy new look, Red Lobster sales continue to tick downward.) Still, like a number of other beleaguered commercial institutions torn asunder by shifting tastes, it sure looks as if Red Lobster has pivoted to virality—hoping to meme its way back into the hearts and minds of the American public.
Caught in the crossfire, of course, are the Red Lobster cooks and waitstaff, who have been asked to return to the infernal battlefields of Endless Shrimp. “We have this training app, and it told me I had a new notification. When I clicked on it, it was about Endless Shrimp,” said a woman we’ll call Mary, who works at an East Coast Red Lobster location and is one of the rare employees who was hired during the brief interregnum after the company’s bankruptcy but before the reintroduction of the promotion. Mary says she was given a week’s notice to prepare for Endless Shrimp, an experience that might be compared to getting drafted to Vietnam in 1972. She wasn’t the only one bracing for impact. Scroll through the Red Lobster subreddit and you’ll find plenty of servers doomsaying about the approaching incursion of shrimp. (“God no … I can’t … unless they let us kick people out after a certain time I just can’t,” read the comment of one imperiled employee.)
“All of my co-workers were like, ‘You have no idea what’s coming,’ ” Mary told me. “Before they brought it back, my co-workers were like, ‘It’s good you started working here after Endless Shrimp days were over.’ ”
Mary’s inaugural Endless Shrimp shift matched up perfectly with the nightmarish visions shared by her colleagues. Her restaurant was slammed with Endless Shrimp die-hards from 6:30 p.m. onward, and Mary raised all the predictable gripes. Endless Shrimp diners didn’t spend much money, and they complained about the slow trickle of food leaving the kitchen—an issue exacerbated by the uncharacteristic dinner rush and a prep-cook shortage. Mary was asked to upsell the guests on other, pricier accoutrements on the Red Lobster menu, thus expanding the slim profit margins, but, in her words, “the people buying Endless Shrimp aren’t going to order a $17 margarita flight.” Instead, Mary spent most the evening circling the dining room, refilling beverages and harvesting sub-15-percent tips. Afterward, when she was home safe and ensconced in her bedroom, she started putting together her résumé in order to look for a new job. (Mary told me that four other servers at her Red Lobster location are prepared to either “give notice or stop showing up.”)
This is also why she was kind enough to send over some truly funny internal Red Lobster documents outlining to her, and the rest of the Red Lobster fleet, how the brand wants its servers to express the virtues of the Endless Shrimp promotion. According to leadership, Endless Shrimp amounts to something greater than just cheap shellfish—it wants consumers to see it as spiritually resonant, in a way a $58 surf-and-turf platter is not.
“When guests see Endless Shrimp back on the menu, they feel heard and valued,” reads the document. Red Lobster then implores its employees to understand that Endless Shrimp is, in fact, “about more than just shrimp.” Instead, it’s “about creating an experience that says, ‘We listen to you.’ That’s Red Lobster hospitality in action.” (A spokesperson for Red Lobster said in a statement that while the company doesn’t “comment on internal documents,” it is focused on the guest experience and that the “return of Endless Shrimp reflects what we’ve heard directly from them.”)
Red Lobster flowchart
Delving further into the documents, I came across what Red Lobster refers to as a “menu matrix,” essentially a flowchart of various Endless Shrimp ordering outcomes that let me in on a little secret. The new version of Endless Shrimp is limited to exactly five dishes: There is “Parrot Isle Coconut Shrimp,” “Walt’s Favorite Shrimp,” “Garlic Shrimp Scampi,” “Marry Me Shrimp,” and, of course, “Shrimp Linguini Alfredo.” That means some heavy hitters, like “Popcorn Shrimp,” “Garlic Shrimp Skewers,” and something called “Crispy Dragon Shrimp” are left on the sidelines. (In the brief, all three of those items are listed under an inscription that reads, “Do Not Recommend.”) However, the guidelines also state that if a guest asks for any of those verboten shrimp options as part of their Endless feast, a server will accommodate them—so long as they follow a script. The interaction is supposed to go like this: A customer orders a refill of Crispy Dragon Shrimp, and the server responds, “These items aren’t on the menu for this promotion, but I would be happy to make an exception for you.”
I would be happy to make an exception for you! My God. It’s perfect. It’s an immaculate marketing koan, engineered to invoke a titter of rules-breaking privilege, truly the spice of life. I thought about how naughty it must feel to schmooze one’s way into contraband Popcorn Shrimp, liberated from the imprisonment of the laminated menu.
Naturally, I needed to try it for myself.
I am fairly certain that the last time I dined at a Red Lobster was in 2013, when I was in deep south Texas to visit a girlfriend’s extended family. I also have a visceral memory of wanting to puke the following morning when the putrefying stench of leftover flounder, brought up to temperature in a microwave, permeated the household. The point is, I never indulged in Endless Shrimp during its heyday, back when it bled the brand dry, which is how I found myself sitting in a booth on the third story of the Red Lobster in Times Square—one of only two locations left in New York City. (The other is located in a mall in Howard Beach, a stone’s throw from John F. Kennedy International Airport.) A friend and I scaled the dark-wood stairway and studied the cardboard placard resting on the table, indeed heralding the prodigal return of Endless Shrimp. It was 1 in the afternoon. We were, if I’m being generous, two of maybe 12 people in the entire restaurant.
Adam Chandler
What the Hell Happened to Wendy’s?
Read More
After internalizing so many horror stories about Endless Shrimp—the ghoulishness of its participants, the toll it takes on everyone who staffs a Red Lobster—I did feel a bit guilty about contributing to the mania. But what made me feel even more guilty, after submitting two orders of Endless Shrimp to a reassuringly placid waiter, was the sudden, unimpeachable realization that said shrimp was incredible. It was, by far, the best time I’ve had in a chain restaurant in ages. My opening salvo of three shrimp dishes included the Coconut Shrimp, the Shrimp Scampi, and Walt’s Favorite Shrimp—which is just a basic fried shrimp. (I was saving my off-the-books orders for future refills.) All of this arrived alongside a side of coleslaw and a fizzing Diet Coke that would be topped off on no fewer than five different occasions across my lunch. I positioned a plate in the center of the table to collect the tails. By the time we left, it had been covered with so many shredded pink exoskeletons that you couldn’t see the white porcelain below.
I conquered my first order of shrimp in record time and was gunning for a refill when our waiter instinctually returned. Here was the moment of truth, a chance to wield my secret knowledge—to game the system. I asked for a Garlic Shrimp Skewer, one of the vaunted Forbidden Dishes, and, to my surprise, my waiter was entirely unfazed. He didn’t even say the line, nor did he tease me, in that good-natured way, for venturing off-menu. No, he just scribbled down my request and, 15 minutes later, brought me a single skewer linked with sautéed shrimp resting on a bed of yellow rice. It’s probably the closest I’ll ever feel to being a con man in my life—high praise for the meager $35 price tag. That’s significantly more expensive than the $20 price tag the promotion carried in 2023—evidence of the seismic inflation roiling beneath our feet—but nevertheless, if you have ever wanted to stuff your face, eating shrimp with the louche decadence of a spoiled Roman patrician, then I do recommend patronizing your local Red Lobster.
We did three refills of shrimp in total. In fact, we wanted to quit after two servings, but our waiter was unmoved by any performance of temperance. He ignored our pleas for the check, instead firmly encouraging us to order one more round of shrimp. It was clear then that we weren’t leaving this Red Lobster until we had tried every variety on the menu. My friend, whose constitution was already wavering, buried her head in her hands when—from behind the kitchen partition—a steaming bowl of Popcorn Shrimp emerged. (She got through maybe three bites before throwing in the towel.) Not all the dishes were winners. The Shrimp Linguini Alfredo looked downright cadaverous on the plate—slimy and uniformly matte-white in that disconcerting way, impossible to salvage no matter how much black pepper I cracked over it. No big deal: We both left satisfied, with our wallets unplundered, and, frankly, that is what an all-you-can-eat outing is supposed to feel like.
-
She’s the Only Sane Celebrity in America. This Is How She Did It.
-
Red Lobster’s Endless Shrimp Is Back. Employees Are Horrified. That Probably Explains the Internal Document They Sent Me.
All at once, I began to understand why Red Lobster brought the promotion back, or at least why people were pining for its return. In an age when the amenities have been dutifully repealed from modernity—where dignity grows scarcer in life’s simplest pleasures—there is euphoria in finding a glitch in the system. The mere sensation of not being scammed has taken on a sanctified meaning. And maybe that’s why Endless Shrimp patrons transform into wanton arrivistes in the dining room, demanding plateful after plateful, with royal panache. Because frankly, after tolerating the humiliation of $24 Caesar salads—$36 if you add chicken—we are left with precious few opportunities to feel as if we’re getting a little treat, which is to say, to feel like the Americans we are.
My stomach admittedly became a little unmoored on the subway ride home—an issue I chalk up to scale more than quality. (We finished up at 3 p.m., and I wouldn’t have another meal till morning.) After breaching the event horizon of shellfish, I don’t think a return trip to Red Lobster is on the docket anytime soon. But I suppose you can call me a fan. They really do let you eat all that shrimp, and that’s beautiful, because they don’t let you do anything anymore.
