Love Island: All Stars is officially back for its third season, and with it means the return of some Islanders we’ve seen quite a few times, as former Love Islanders head back to the Villa for another shot at love.
During the season 3 premiere episode, fans of the show were shocked to see the return of Scott van-der-Sluis, who is now making his fourth appearance in a Love Island franchise. And he’s not the only one coming back for more. Day 3 saw the return of Samie Elishi, who is doing her third stint on Love Island.
Scott and Samie are now part of a select group of Love Islanders who have done multiple appearances on the show, but who has been on the most? We’ve ranked the seven Islanders who have done three or more appearances on the show, and the answers may surprise you.
Casey O’Gorman
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 4
Which editions have they appeared on? Love Island season 9 (2023), Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024) and season 2 (2025), and Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
We all know it—Casey O’Gorman is tied for the Love Islander who has made the most appearances on the show.
He first showed up on the winter series in 2023, where he developed connections with Claudia and Rosie, and ended up leaving the show with Rosie, but their relationship didn’t go any further. He then appeared on the first season of All Stars, but was only in the Villa for a few days before getting dumped.
Casey then appeared on the second season of All Stars, but this time entered on day two, and ended up winning the show with Gabby Allen. The pair dated for a few months before ultimately breaking up.
However, that wasn’t the end of Casey’s Love Island journey, as he then made an appearance on Love Island Games at the end of last year, which he appeared on alongside his ex Gabby.
Could there be a fifth appearance on the cards with a surprise All Stars season three return?
Scott van-der-Sluis
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 4
Which editions have they appeared on? Love Island season 10 (2023), Love Island USA season 5 (2023), Love Island Games season 1 (2023), and Love Island: All Stars season 3 (2026)
Summer 2023 was the summer of Scott on Love Island. He first appeared on the show in early summer 2023 in season 10, where he developed a connection with Catherine Agbaje, but they didn’t end up together.
Then, just days after being dumped from the Villa, he turned up on Love Island USA. After an unsuccessful go on that show, he then later that summer featured in Love Island Games.
And now, after a few years away, he’s back for the third season of All Stars, which he says will be his last time on the show.
Toby Aromolaran
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 4
Which editions have they appeared on? Love Island season 7 (2021), Love Island Games seasons 1 (2023) and 2 (2025), and Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024)
Toby is often overlooked when it comes to Islanders with the most appearances, but he’s actually tied with Casey and Scott.
We first met Toby during season seven, where he had a memorable relationship with Chloe Burrows, and the pair ended up as runners-up of the series. They were together for a decent amount time after the show but ultimately broke up. Toby then went onto Love Island Games in 2023, where he formed a connection with Georgia Steel, which continued when the pair went on the first season of All Stars.
Toby wasn’t done with Love Island though, as last year he appeared on the second season of Love Island Games. Despite going on the show four times, he has never won.
Gabby Allen
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 3
Which editions have they appeared on? Love Island season 3 (2017), Love Island: All Stars season 2 (2025), and Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
Gabby first appeared on Love Island in season three, where she coupled up with Marcel Somerville and the pair had a super strong relationship throughout and placed fourth. They ended up staying together for nearly a year after.
Gabby then returned to Love Island last year for the second series of All Stars, which she ended up winning with Casey O’Gorman. The couple stayed together for a few months and then split up before then going onto Love Island Games, where they did not reunite.
Georgia Steel
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 3
Which editions have they appeared on? Love Island season 4 (2018), Love Island Games season 1 (2023), and Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024)
She’s loyal, babe! And loyal to Love Island, as she’s been on the show three times. She first appeared in 2018 where she had that memorable relationship with Josh Denzel and that epic Casa Amor return, where she told him she was loyal.
Five years later, she then returned and took part in the first season of Love Island Games, where she developed a connection with Toby, and the pair then both appeared on the first season of Love Island: All Stars. They didn’t win, but they stayed together for most of the series and placed fourth. They’re not together anymore, though.
Lucinda Strafford
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 3
Which editions have they appeared on?: Love Island season 7 (2021), Love Island Australia (2023), and Love Island Games (2025)
Lucinda has had a truly international Love Island experience. Her first time on the show was back in 2021 for season seven, and she became part of a trio with Chloe Burrows and Millie Court. She then went on Love Island Australia, where she formed a connection with Zac Nunn and the pair made it all the way to the final, but were ultimately runners-up. They stayed together for a few months before breaking up.
Lucinda then went on Love Island Games last year, which she ended up winning with Love Island USA’s Isaiah Campbell. However, the pair is no longer together.
Samie Elishi
ITV
Number of Love Island appearances: 3
Which editions have they appeared on?: Love Island season 9 (2023), Love Island: All Stars season 2 (2025), and Love Island: All Stars season 3 (2026)
Samie has just earned her third Love Island appearance after she entered the Villa during the fourth episode of the new All Stars series. We first met Samie during Love Island season nine, where she was a main figure on the series and got into a relationship with Tom Clare while on the show. However, the pair ended up splitting a few months after leaving.
Samie then returned to All Stars last year but was a late arrival and only had a few days on the show before she was dumped from the Villa. Hopefully she will get more of a chance to make a mark in season three.
